More Pages: Gettysburg Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23


Excellent topic about a bloody phase of the battle
Great coverage and insight!Jorgensen was very clear on positioning and skipped the popular controvercy of the 2nd Day battle which may make some of the more educated Gettysburg Battle students happy to know. Jorgensen briefly mentions Lee's decisions, Sickle's movement or Longstreet's countermarch which I found refreshing. Instead, Jorgensen places you the reader alongside Anderson, Barksdale, Kershaw and others as they press forward into action in the late afternoon of the 2nd. As always I ask for maps and this book had plenty that I could use during the reading to understand the terrain and unit positions during the battle. It was great to look at the maps and see how they progressed as the action unfolded throughout the book and units either advanced or retreated.
Jay Jorgensen has put together a fine book on this seldom written about subject of the Wheatfield that I feel was very important to the outcome at Gettysburg. Though catastrophic to both sides, carrying this section of land was vital to Union success in regards to building a foundation for day 3. Jorgensens complete work was very exciting to read as he captures a lot of the action in regards to soldier personal accounts being added, descriptive fighting and bloodshed. This book is very thorough and covers the entire timeline of the Wheatfield battle. I highly recommend this book! 5 STARS!!!!!


The Civil War and the Common Man
A wonderful Civil War human- interest storyMark Dunkelman vividly paints a splendid picture of Amos Humiston and his family, taking us through a journey of their trails and tribulations. Mark Dunkelman's painstaking research comes togther with a marvelous, moving, and timeless human-interest story.


Mort at his bestThe pictures are crips and the stories about them are quite intersting. It's interesting to see his liberal use of the various histical data and how it was applied to find out more about the background of each print.
If you are a Mort Kunstler fan then this is the book for you.
Mort Kunstler is an awesome artist.

A "Letters" Book Plus A Lot More
An outstanding, invaluable, core title addition

I read this wonderful book twice!
Excellent! We couldn't put it down!

The Butcher's BillThe title is mildly misleading. Many of the soldiers referenced died of wounds in the month after the battle. This in no way minimizes their sacrifice, but these are not exclusively eyewitnesses accounts of soldiers immediately KIA.
One of the more intriguing aspects of the book is the presentation of letters to next of kin by commanding officers and fellow soldiers. Those letters reflect the ethos of the Civil War soldier, as well as the diction and eloquence of a more gracious age. Contrast the poignant sense of loss and appreciation reflected in those letters with the sterile form letter-notification of the 20th Century.
A companion piece from the Confederate side would be a valuable accompaniment to this scholarly work.
Outstanding.....A must for any Civil War collection!!!!!!!!

A Remarkable Work on a Remarkable ManIn this book, the editor of the papers of John Calhoun tells the story of one of the defenders of Calhoun's principles, James Johnston Pettigrew. The portrait is of a man who is engaging and noble.
When you visit Gettysburg, stand at the North Carolina monument and gaze across the field at the copse of trees; you will be standing at the spot where Pettigrew and his men began their march to glory. As Wilson's portrait of Pettigrew makes clear, and as any serious and honest student of the struggle for Southern independence should know, these were men who fought for a variety of reasons. In Pettigrew's case, it was to preserve a substantial measure of the world that America had inherited from Europe against a foe bent on destroying that world in the name of an abstract principle.
These were not, in short and contrary to the simplistic explanations of the conflict that dominate public discourse today, men who marched into the cannon's mouth with dreams of masters whipping slaves in their hearts. On the contrary, they were men who believed fervently that they were resisting the tyranny of a government that was fighting to keep them where they would rather not be; and in this, they, not Lincoln and his generals, were the real heirs of the American Revolution.
It is through reading the work of scholars like Professor Wilson that we can honestly approximate the reasons for this last (on the Confederate side) just as well as necessary war in America's story. For unlike this rather partisan review, the book is soberly written and the story unfolds in the measured tones of a man who has absorbed the lessons of his heroes.
The lost son of the Confederacy

An amazing achievement
Excellent analysis & meditation of events from November.

The human side of the War
An amazing story!

The tragedy and horror of warMany families of southern soldiers made the trek up north to claim their loved ones and take them back for burial in the south. Unfortunately, many families returned to the south empty-handed because they could simply not find where their beloved son, father, or brother were buried. This was a too common tale on both southern and northern families during the war.
Coco describes how southern soldiers were mortally wounded and ultimately buried after the battle. Most were buried hastily and thus today, their grave location is unknown.
This makes the battlefield and the land around it even more hallowed. It dosen't matter what side of the Civil War a reader of this book is for, we should all be somber and respectful to these brave soldiers of both the North and South who fought and paid the ultimate sacrifice of their beliefs.
This book is fascinating, accurate, and articulate and I highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in the Battle of Gettysburg and the Civil War.
Wasted Valor
In the Wheatfield many brigades from the Confederate and Union Armies were thrust against each other at very close range and thus tragic and bloody events followed. The Confederate Brigades(mainly the Georgia, South Carolina, Arkansas, and Texas Brigades) fought at close quarter against the Union Brigades (mainly Pennsylvania, Michigan, and New York). In three long hours Jorgenson describes how lines of companies on both sides were simply decimated by intense firing of rifles, artillery, and hand-to-hand combat.
Jorgenson has made this intense phase of the Battle easy to understand and his maps and visual aids tremendously helps readers gain an understanding of how this struggle for the Wheatfield and beyond developed.
Both sides lost a tremendous amount of men, Jorgenson describes how not only dead soldiers filled the wheatfield but also hats, rifles, bayonets, personal items, and gruesomely, body parts of arms, legs, heads, and entrails littered the ground. This was a very climatic and bloody struggle. Both sides had tragic loss of men and material. Yet, the battle waged on all around them.
The Battle of Gettysburg was eventually a Union victory, however, the Wheatfield was not a clear victory for either side. Jorgenson acurately summarizes that the Confederate soldiers who fought and died became a commodity the Confederacy and the Army of Northern Virginia could hardly afford to replace.
I highly recommend this book to those who are interested in the Battle of Gettysburg, Civil War Historians and enthusiasts, and those who enjoy a very well written book.